Takeaways from the new report by Pew on Installment Lending

by
Adam Rust

The Pew Center issued a new report on small-dollar loans last week. The report's findings describe how non-bank lenders issue installment credit to subprime consumers. Pew reviewed PACER filings for 296 contracts made by fourteen lenders.

All-in APRs are higher, sometimes much higher, than the stated APR. An all-in APR used statutorily for the supervision of loans originated to service members under the Military Lending Act, covers all of the costs associated with financing a loan. When the price of insuring the loans studied by Pew was factored into an all-in-APR, the average cost jumped well beyond 40 percent. In its research, Pew found that an all-in APR was higher and that with loans of smaller size, the all-in-APR often ended up closer to 90 percent.

Installment loans often came with ancillary products. In the great majority of the loans in Pew's sample, consumers paid for add-ons like auto club memberships and credit insurance.

Only 1 in 5 loans were made to new borrowers. The rest were made to refinance loans or to write a new loan to a previous customer. Approximately two of every three loans were originated consecutively. Pew found one instance where a Colorado consumer refinanced a loan 37 times – paying $1,980 to borrow $200. In focus groups, borrowers reported that lenders marketed the opportunity to renew loans.

Picture of card
Picture of card
Picture of card
Picture of card

Because some lenders create repayment schedules using the Rule of 78ths, borrowers who refinanced paid even more to borrow. The Rule of 78ths reduces the share of payments that go toward repayment of principal during the early stages of the payback period. In the contracts reviewed by Pew that used this technique, lenders were able to collect 20 percentage points more in interest during the life of renewed loans.

The low loss ratios on credit insurance policies reflect low value to consumers. Seventy-nine percent of loans surveyed included the purchase of at least one credit insurance policies. In reviewing reports published by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners ("NAIC"), loss ratios ranged from as low as 19 percent for involuntary unemployment insurance to 66 percent for credit life. NAIC's working group on credit insurance has stated that a loss ratio of less than 60 percent represents poor value for consumers.

Back Arrow icon
Back to list of blog posts
The Wisewage blog is not intended to describe any particular product mentioned elsewhere on the site. Please refer to each product page for details about any specific product. You can read our full legal statement about the blog here.
Thank you! Your subscription request has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.